Get ready to host the ultimate Halloween murder mystery party! With themes ranging from haunted theatres to chilling seances, these murder mystery party games are sure to make your 2024 Halloween unforgettable. Gather your funnest friends, dress up in your best costumes, and unravel the mysteries for a Halloween no one will ever forget. Here are our top mystery games for 2024!
1. The Phantom of the Theatre
Step into the historic Moxey Theatre for an unforgettable triple murder investigation. As the cast and crew prepare for opening night, mysterious accidents and ghostly apparitions lead to a shocking series of events. Is the Phantom of the Theatre to blame, or is there a more sinister plot afoot?
Angel Rating:
Four
Difficulty Rating:
Medium to High
Who it’s Perfect For:
Ideal for those who enjoy a clean mystery with no adult content
Costumes:
Optional, but vintage theatre attire could enhance the experience.
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
This theme offers a spooky atmosphere without being overly Halloween-centric, making it versatile and easy to host.
Take it to the Next Level:
Transform your space into a vintage theatre with red velvet drapes and dim lighting to create an authentic atmosphere.
2. Murder at the Seance
Join renowned psychic Melody McCoy at Lively Manor for a seance that spirals into chaos when a vengeful spirit and a shocking murder disrupt the evening. Can you uncover the truth hidden in the shadows?
Angel Rating:
Four
Difficulty Rating:
High
Who it’s Perfect For:
Perfect for seasoned hosts looking for a challenging mystery.
Costumes:
Modern or Victorian-era attire, or even steampunk for a unique twist.
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
This is our newest Halloween-themed game with phenomenal reviews and a Ghost Story Expansion Pack to help you and your guests immerse yourselves further in the chilling backstory.
Take it to the Next Level:
Host in a dimly lit room with flickering candles and eerie sound effects to enhance the seance experience.
3. A Vampire Murder
In the secluded Casillero de la Sombra, the Antonov Clan of vampires faces a shocking betrayal when their leader is found staked in his coffin. Who would dare defy the vampire code?
Angel Rating:
Four
Difficulty Rating:
Medium
Who it’s Perfect For:
Those who love a classic vampire theme with a gothic twist.
Costumes:
Vampire attire with capes, fangs, and dramatic makeup.
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
The Gothic setting and vampire intrigue make it a timeless choice for Halloween.
Take it to the Next Level:
Set the scene with candlelit rooms, dark drapes, and eerie music for an immersive vampire experience.
4. The Halloween Party Murder
At Ben and Aria Tate’s extravagant Halloween bash, a chilling video reveals the brutal murder of a guest. As fear spreads, it’s clear the killer is among the party goers. Can you solve the mystery before it’s too late?
Angel Rating:
Three
Difficulty Rating:
Medium
Who it’s Perfect For:
Non-conservative audiences who enjoy a thrilling party with adult themes.
Costumes:
Halloween costumes with a glamorous or spooky twist.
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
The combination of glamour and horror makes it a standout choice for a thrilling Halloween night.
Take it to the Next Level:
Incorporate a live DJ and dramatic lighting to keep the energy high and the suspense palpable.
5. The Haunted Island Murders
Ten years after a fateful party on a haunted island, the past comes back to haunt a group of friends. As they return at the request of a presumed-dead friend, they must solve the mystery before becoming the next victims.
Angel Rating:
Three
Difficulty Rating:
Medium to High
Who it’s Perfect For:
Anyone seeking a Halloween party with a twist and multiple murders to solve.
Costumes:
Casual island attire or ghostly costumes for added thrill.
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
The island setting and layered mystery offer a unique and engaging experience.
Take it to the Next Level:
Use fog machines and ambient sounds of the ocean to create an eerie island atmosphere.
6. Salem Witches
The year is 1692 and Salem Town is in the midst of what would become the most famous witch hunt in American history. Many residents of Salem share a dark, damp cell where they sit in the dirt awaiting their trial, with nothing else to do but contemplate their fates.
Ann Putnam, a major accuser in the witch hunt, is berating the other inmates when, suddenly, there is a blinding flash of light and a deafening bang! By the time the captives regained their sight and the smoke dissipated, Ann Putnam lay dead beside the now open cell door.
Under threat of everyone being hung at Gallows Hill that very night, those accused must find the person responsible for Ann Putnam’s death. Was it an act of witchcraft? Are there witches in the cell, and if so, who? And who killed Goodwife Putnam?
Those looking for a witches-themed mystery game that’s more focused on the true to the history, less focused on women cackling and flying on broomsticks
Angel Rating:
Three
Difficulty Rating:
Low to Medium
Who it’s Perfect For:
Those looking for a witches-themed mystery game that’s more focused on the true to the history, less focused on women cackling and flying on broomsticks
Costumes:
You, as the host, can decide!
Why it’s Perfect for Your 2024 Halloween Party:
This locked-room mystery gets your guests sleuthing in a whole new way, since the murder took place in front of everyone in the prison!
Take it to the Next Level:
Transform your space into a 17th-century Salem setting with rustic decor and dim lighting. Use hay bales, wooden barrels, and lanterns to create an authentic atmosphere.
Ready to host? Check out all of our Halloween mystery game kits here!
Need some Halloween party inspiration? Our Pinterest boards will inspire you to throw the Halloween party no one will ever forget!
