Difficult Murder Mystery Party Game Packages

For those who love a challenge (we’re looking at you, our repeat clients and serial mystery party hosts!) these are the murder mystery game kits for you! While still in our one-of-a-kind Mingle Mystery format, these mystery game packages are the most challenging ones we offer.

The next question our repeat hosts as us is, of course, “What’s the hardest mystery kit you carry?” To which we reply, “Well, that all depends on your guests, their level of deductive reasoning etc etc etc.”

But let’s just say, as of this moment, the answer is Murder at the Seance.

Nope, Phantom of the Theatre. Wait – it’s Murder in Venice. NO! Haunted Island Murders…. guess you’ll just have to solve them all and let us know which one you think is the most challenging murder mystery game SHOT carries!

The Phantom of the Theatre

Join the cast and crew of The Blue Lady at the historic Moxey Theatre for a TRIPLE MURDER investigation no one will ever forget! Renowned Broadway director Olivier Lyons has purchased the dilapidated Moxey Opera House and spent two years restoring it, all to put on his production of The Blue Lady, a tale of crime and betrayal based on a true story.

The New Years Eve Murder Mystery Party

On New Years Eve, inside the Moxey Estate, a very special celebration is taking place, and the world is watching. At the stroke of midnight, a time-locked safe will be opened, revealing the biggest secret of infamous adventurer and archaeologist Holt Moxey's life.

Murder at the Seance Murder Mystery Party

Immerse yourself and your friends in an exhilarating journey of intrigue, secrets, and spectral whispers as you step into the shadowy secrets of The Murder at the Seance.

How Alan Puckett Kicked the Bucket Murder Mystery Party

The thing that everyone thought but never said was that the neighbourhood would be a much better place when he finally kicked the bucket. So when Alan Puckett was actually murdered, the list of suspects seemed never-ending.

The Haunted Island Murders Mystery Party Game

Ten years ago A group of teens went out to an island for a party What happened that night has haunted them ever since And one... never returned.

Murder on the Continental Express

A train themed murder mystery party set on a train trip across Africa in the tradition of Murder on the Orient Express but in murder mystery party form. Can accommodate an unlimited number of players as sleuths or investigators. Instant download materials!

Murder in Wonderland Mystery Party Game

It has been two weeks since Alice's initial visit to Wonderland, when she went on her crazy adventure after following a rabbit carrying a pocket watch. But when The Caterpillar is found murdered below his mushroom, Alice and all the other residents of Wonderland become suspects in a murder investigation, as well as under suspicion to determine who, or what, drove everyone in Wonderland mad!

Murder in Venice Masquerade Murder Mystery Game

A masquerade themed murder mystery party set in a building in Venice, Italy. but in murder mystery party form. Can accommodate an unlimited number of players as sleuths or investigators. Instant download materials!

By Angel Rating

By Difficulty